Executives, Are You Satisfied with Your Recruiting Results?
(1265 words)
Executives, are you happy with your company’s recruiting results? Are you attracting the top performers your business needs to grow? Or are you simply filling open positions and hoping you hired the right people?
Here’s a tougher question. If your recruiting results are falling short of expectations, are you willing to change your Talent Acquisition process?
Many executives invest considerable time developing strategies to increase sales, improve operations, and strengthen profitability. Yet when it comes to recruiting, they continue using the same processes year after year, even when those processes fail to attract the talent their businesses need.
Why?
Perhaps it’s because recruiting has traditionally been viewed as an HR function rather than a critical business process. But consider this: Your company cannot consistently achieve its business goals without attracting the people capable of achieving them.
Nearly every company has a recruiting process. The real question is whether that process produces the results your business requires.
Today, let’s examine two practices that may be preventing your company from attracting top performers.
1. Are You Courting Top Talent or Praying They Apply?
Does your company’s Talent Acquisition process depend on the best and most talented candidates somehow discovering your generally poorly written job descriptions? Then do you expect those candidates to happily complete lengthy application forms before finally submitting their résumés?
And then what? Wait patiently for someone to contact them?
Executives, would YOU accept this process if someone were recruiting you?
During my consulting career, I have asked hundreds of executives that question while working on contract with their companies.
Would you like to guess how many said yes?
Fewer than ten!
Interesting, isn’t it? Executives expect top talent to tolerate a recruiting process they would never accept themselves.
Generally, executive searches are conducted differently. Executive Search firms frequently charge fees of 30% to 40% of an executive’s expected annual compensation. Why are companies willing to pay those fees?
Because experienced Executive Search professionals understand something that many corporate recruiting processes overlook.
Top performers expect to be courted, not processed!
You may be wondering, “Bill, what makes you qualified to make that statement?”
I’m glad you asked!
From 1981 through 1989, I worked in fee-based recruiting. Twice, I led EG Jones, a recruiting company with 14 recruiters across three offices in Washington, D.C., Baltimore, and Philadelphia, in recruiting fees generated.
I wasn’t sitting around waiting for the perfect candidate to answer a classified advertisement. I was identifying talented professionals, building relationships, understanding their career goals, and introducing them to opportunities worth considering.
Several clients would call me on a Monday with an interesting proposition.
“Bill, if you introduce us to the right candidate before Friday, we’ll cancel our classified advertisement scheduled for Sunday’s Washington Post.”
They never ran those ads!
Speaking of The Washington Post, I became so familiar with its Data Processing Department’s talent needs that I could identify qualified IT professionals and move quickly.
On one occasion, I contacted an IT Manager and informed him that I had scheduled a candidate to interview with him at 9 AM the following morning.
When I called the candidate to confirm her appointment, I explained that she would interview with three IT Managers. I also told her that I expected she would receive a job offer before 11 AM.
After the interviews, the Manager called me.
“Bill, you got me in trouble!”
“What did I do?”
“All three managers want to hire her!”
Now THAT is the kind of recruiting problem I enjoy creating!
I reminded him that the candidate was expecting an offer by 11 AM.
“Will do!” he replied.
At precisely 11 AM, my phone rang. It was the Manager.
“She accepted!”
Fifteen minutes later, the candidate called me.
“He extended the offer, and I accepted! How did you know he was going to extend me an offer that quickly?”
My response was simple.
“I know my clients.”
Think about what just happened. Three managers recognized the value of the same candidate. The company made a hiring decision immediately, and the candidate enthusiastically accepted the offer.
No weeks of waiting. No endless interviews. No wondering whether anyone would ever call her back.
That is what happens when recruiting is treated as a relationship-driven business process rather than an administrative exercise.
How did I develop the relationships and recruiting process that made those results possible?
Read next week’s Talent Attraction Tuesday, November 24, 2026!
2. Are You Avoiding Reference Checks Because Someone Says You Could Get Sued?
Here’s another question I frequently ask executives who complain that they cannot find candidates who fit their company’s culture.
“What questions do you ask during reference checks?”
The response is remarkably consistent.
“Human Resources told us to stop conducting reference checks because we could get sued!”
Really?
My next question is simple.
“Have you asked anyone to show you the actual statistics on lawsuits arising from employment reference checks?”
I went looking for those statistics myself. While I found discussions of legal risks associated with reference checking, I could not find a comprehensive national count of lawsuits specifically arising from employment references.
That does not mean such lawsuits don’t exist. It means we should examine the evidence rather than make decisions based entirely on fear.
Consider the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s Fiscal Year 2025 statistics.
The EEOC received 88,201 new employment discrimination charges and filed 94 merits lawsuits. The lawsuits involved allegations including discrimination, retaliation, harassment, termination, and other employment practices.
These are charges and lawsuits, respectively, not interchangeable statistics. The EEOC figures also do not provide a comprehensive count of private lawsuits involving reference checks.
But they raise an important question.
Why do companies sometimes abandon a valuable recruiting practice without first examining the actual risks and how to manage them?
Of course, reference checks must be conducted professionally, consistently, and legally. Employers should obtain appropriate authorization, ask job-related questions, document responses, and follow applicable laws.
There are genuine legal risks, including defamation and negligent referral. But avoiding meaningful reference checks can create risks of its own.
Let’s face another business reality.
Nearly every important management decision carries some degree of legal risk. Hiring employees, terminating employees, evaluating performance, managing compensation, and making promotion decisions all require sound judgment.
Are you going to close your company because someone says, “You could get sued”?
Of course not!
You identify the risks, establish appropriate procedures, and make informed business decisions.
Why should reference checking be any different?
On Tuesday, December 1, 2026, my Talent Attraction Tuesday article will explain my approach to Proper Reference Checking and how it can help companies make better-informed hiring decisions.
Talent Attraction or Talent Acquisition? You Decide!
After more than four decades in recruiting, I have learned that Talent Attraction mirrors the Sales Process.
Successful sales professionals don’t simply advertise their products and pray that customers appear. They identify prospects, establish relationships, understand needs, demonstrate value, and earn the opportunity to do business.
Why should recruiting be different?
Traditional Talent Acquisition processes often emphasize administration, applications, compliance, and moving candidates through a system.
Those activities have their place. But processing candidates is not the same as attracting top performers.
Talent Attraction is proactive. Talent Acquisition is too often reactive.
Executives, which approach is more likely to attract the people your business needs to achieve its goals?
And more importantly, are you willing to change your recruiting process to achieve better results?
EXPECT SUCCESS!
Bill Humbert
The RecruiterGuy
Talent Attraction Consultant | International Professional Speaker | Author
Coming January 2027: THUMBS UP! How Hitchhiking 15,000 Miles Taught Me The Power of Proper Goal Setting
Permission to Reprint Articles by Bill Humbert
Permission is granted to all print, broadcast, and electronic media to reprint articles authored by Bill Humbert, provided the following conditions are met:
- Inclusion of Contact Information
- The article’s closing bio and contact information must be included in full.
- For electronic publications, a live, clickable link to https://www.RecruiterGuy.com must be included within the body of the article.
- Provision of Published Copies
- For print publications, one physical copy of the publication featuring the article must be mailed to:
Provocative Thinking Consulting, Inc.
2590 Norwich St.
Fitchburg, WI 53711 - Fee for Non-Compliance
- A fee of $300 per article will be charged for articles published without the closing bio and contact information.
- Editing and Adjustments
- Permission includes reasonable edits for:
a. Content updates and industry-specific examples.
b. Adjustments to article length.
c. Changes to article titles. - Electronic Publishing Requirements
- All electronic publications must include a live, clickable link to https://www.RecruiterGuy.com.
For any questions or clarifications, don’t hesitate to get in touch with Bill Humbert at Bill@RecruiterGuy.com.
Bill Humbert’s Bio
With over 40 years of expertise as a Professional Talent Attraction Consultant and 26+ years as an Expert Career Coach, Bill Humbert is uniquely positioned to speak, author, and consult on Talent Attraction, Career Search, and Goal Setting.
Having presented to audiences on three continents (Europe, Africa, and North America), Bill’s career began in 1981 as a fee-based recruiter in Washington, D.C. In 1990, he founded his consulting business, shifting to a flat monthly fee model and successfully serving companies across diverse industries, including telecom, construction, financial services, manufacturing, management consulting, and renewable energy.
Notably, Bill recruited the Chief Operating Officer for a restaurant chain, with her tenure starting on March 1, 2023.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, Bill demonstrated thought leadership by authoring 104 consecutive weeks of #TalentAttractionTuesday and #JobSearchFriday blogs, which are available on RecruiterGuy.com. He has a rich Article Bank with 400+ Articles.
As a career coach, he has guided hundreds of professionals toward successful career transitions over the past 26 years. He is also the author of three career search books, including the highly acclaimed EXPECT SUCCESS! The Science of the Over 50 Career Search, which received a 5-star review on readersfavorite.com/book-review/expect-success
THUMBS UP! How I hitchhiked 15,000Miles and Learned The Secret to Achieving Any Goal – A Business book disguised as an Adventure Story, will be published on January 20, 2027!
ALT text for article bank – Bill Humbert, Talent Attraction Consultant and career coach, shares strategies for finding Talent who never post for positions online.
